'I must go down there, Watson. I must,' said Sherlock Holmes at the breakfast table on Thursday morning.
'Go? Go where?' I asked.
'To Dartmoor — to King's Pyland.'
'Ah! So that's it,' I said. 'Well, everybody in the country is talking about the case at King's Pyland.'
I always know when Holmes is interested in a case. He reads all the newspapers, he walks up and down, up and down the room, and does not speak for hours.
He did all those things yesterday. He did not answer any of my questions, but I knew that it was the mystery at King's Pyland.
The morning newspapers were on the breakfast table. 'What is happening at King's Pyland? Where is Silver Blaze?' they asked. 'Who killed John Straker? What are the police doing? Can they find the horse before the big race next week?'
Silver Blaze was a famous racehorse, and John Straker was his trainer. One of the biggest horse races of the year — the Wessex Cup — was next week, and Silver Blaze was the favourite to win. But on Monday night at King's Pyland two things happened. Someone killed John Straker, and Silver Blaze disappeared.
I was interested in this case too. 'Do you need my help, Holmes?' I asked. 'I would very much like to come with you.'
'My dear Watson,' said Holmes, 'of course you must come with me. We can catch the twelve o'clock from Paddington, and talk about the case on the train.'
Two hours later we were on the train to Tavistock. We read all the midday newspapers, but there was nothing new in them.
'So, Watson, what do you think about this case?'
'Well, the newspapers say-'
'Ah, yes. The newspapers understand nothing. One day they say one thing, the next day they say another. But we must look at the case more carefully. What did happen on Monday night at King's Pyland? And what did not happen? That's an important question too.'
'Do the police have any answers?' I asked.
'No,' said Holmes. 'On Wednesday morning I had two letters. One was from Mr Ross, the owner of the horse, and the other was from the Dartmoor police — an Inspector Gregory. They ask for my help.'
'Wednesday morning!' I cried. 'But this is Thursday morning. Why didn't you go down yesterday?'
'Because it was an easy case. You can't hide a famous horse for long, I thought. Where can you hide a horse on Dartmoor? There are no buildings, no trees… But I was wrong, Watson. The case is now two days old, and nobody can find the horse — or Straker's killer. So here we are, on the train to Tavistock.'
'And what do you think about it all?' I said.
'Well, Watson, let's look at the case. First, we have a racehorse, Silver Blaze — only five years old, but already a winner in many big races. His owner, Mr Ross, is a happy man — and rich. The racegoers are happy too. Silver Blaze nearly always wins his races, and so people put big bets on him to win. And when the favourite wins the race, a lot of people make money on their bets. But what happens when the favourite doesn't win, Watson? What then?'
'A lot of people lose their money, of course,' I said. 'And people with big bets on a different horse can make much more money, when that other horse wins.'
'Right, Watson! So perhaps some people are very interested in Silver Blaze not running in the Wessex Cup. Of course, Mr Ross and his trainer, John Straker, know that, and they watch the horse very carefully.
'Now, let's look at the people and the place. The trainer, John Straker — a good man and wonderful with horses — worked for Mr Ross for twelve years. There are four horses in the training stables, and three boys working for Straker. One of them sits up all night with the horses, and the other two sleep in a room over the stables. We know nothing bad about any of the boys.
'Straker has a wife, no children, and lives — I mean, lived — in a house about two hundred metres from the stables. The town of Tavistock is two kilometres to the west, and about two kilometres to the East there is Capleton, another training stables. The owner there is Lord Backwater, and the trainer is Silas Brown. There are no other houses — just the hills of Dartmoor.'
I listened carefully. I wanted to remember it all because Holmes does not like to say anything twice.
'Now,' he said, 'what happened on Monday night? These papers came with Inspector Gregory's letter. The best thing is for you to read them, Watson. Then tell me what you think.'
I took the papers from him, and began to read.
Monday night at Kind's Pyland
Notes by Inspector Gregory, after talking to Edith Baxter; Ned Hunter, Mrs John Straker, and Mr Fitzroy Simpson.
On Monday evening Straker locked the stables at nine o'clock, the usual time. Two of the boys then walked up to the trainer's house for their dinner, but the third boy, Ned Hunter, stayed in the stables to watch the horses. At five past nine, the Strakers' servant, a girl called Edith Baxter, carried Ned Hunter's dinner down to the stables. The dinner that night was a hot meat curry.
Edith was nearly at the stables when a man called out to her. He came up to her, and she saw a tall man in a grey suit and a hat, and a red and black scarf. He carried a big walking stick, and Edith felt afraid of him.
'Where am I?' the man asked. 'What is this place?' 'This is King's Pyland training stables,' she said. 'Good!' said the man. 'Now, a stable boy sleeps here every night — is that right? And I think you're taking his dinner to him now.' He took an envelope out of his pocket. 'Please give the boy this, and you can have some money for a beautiful new dress.'
Edith did not take the envelope. She ran past the man to the stables and up to a small open window. She always put the boy's dinner through this window, and Ned Hunter was there, ready to take it.
'Oh Ned!' Edith cried, but before she could say any more, the stranger came up behind her.
'Good evening' he said through the window to the boy. 'I want to talk to you.'
'Who are you? What do you want?' Ned Hunter said.
'I want to make you rich, boy' the stranger said. 'You help me, and I help you. You have two horses in for the Wessex Cup — Silver Blaze and Bayard. I hear that Bayard is the better horse, and that you stable boys are putting your bets on him to win. Am I right?'
'I'm not saying anything' cried Ned Hunter. 'We don't talk about our horses at King's Pyland, so get out! I'm getting the dog now!'
Ned ran across the stables to get the dog, and Edith began to run back to the house. But she looked back after about thirty metres, and saw the man at the little window, with his head and one arm inside the room.
Edith ran on, and a minute later, Ned came out of the building and locked the door behind him. He ran all round the stables with the dog, but the man was gone.
Ned Hunter told the trainer and the other boys about the stranger, but no one saw him again.
The next thing happened at one o'clock in the morning when John Straker got out of bed.
'What's the matter?' said his wife. 'Where are you going?'
'To the stables' Straker said. 'I can't stop thinking about that stranger. I just want to have a look around.'
'But it's raining. Wait until the rain stops,' she said.
'No, no' Straker said. 'I want to go now.'
He left the house and Mrs Straker went back to sleep. At seven in the morning she woke up, but her husband was not there. She quickly got up, called the servant, Edith, and they ran down to the stables.
They found the stables unlocked. Straker was not there, and inside, on a chair, Ned Hunter slept like a dead man. Silver Blaze was gone, and his stable door was open. They called the other two boys from the room over the stables. They were good sleepers and heard nothing in the night.
Nobody could wake Ned Hunter, so the two women and the boys ran out to look for the trainer and the horse. Five hundred metres from the stables, they saw Straker's coat on a small tree. Down the hill, just past the tree, they found the trainer. He was dead.
There was a long cut in his leg, and his head was broken in three places. In his right hand he had a small knife, with blood all over it, and in his left hand he had a red and black scarf.
Edith Baxter knew the scarf at once, and later, so did Ned Hunter.
'It's the stranger's scarf,' he told us. 'When I went to get the dog, that stranger was still at the stable window. He put something in my meat curry, to make me sleep know he did. Edith saw him, with his arm through the window.'
Ned Hunter was right about his meat curry. There was some of his dinner left, and we found a lot of opium in it. That's why Ned slept like a dead man. What about the horse? We found his tracks in the mud, next to Straker's dead body. But what happened then? Someone hit Straker on the head, and killed him. Did that person take the horse away? Did the horse run away? Everybody on Dartmoor is looking for Silver Blaze, but there is no news of him.
When I began work on the case on Tuesday, we looked for the stranger. He was in Tavistock, and we found him easily. His name is Fitzroy Simpson. He lives mostly in London, and makes his money at the races, taking bets. We looked in his betting-book, and found a number of big bets — five thousand pounds — against the favourite for the Wessex Cup.
These were his answers to my questions.
'Why did you come down to Dartmoor?'
'I'm a betting man, Inspector. I need to know about the horses for the Wessex Cup — Silver Blaze, Bayard, and Desborough, the horse at Silas Brown's stables. He's the second favourite for the race, you see.'
'Did you go to the King's Pyland stables late on Monday evening?'
'Yes, I did. I just wanted to ask the stable boys some questions. They know the horses better than anyone.'
'And is this your scarf?'
'Yes… yes, it is.'
'And how did it get into the dead man's hand, Mr Simpson? Can you tell us that?'
'I don't know, Inspector, I don't know! I never saw the man. I lost my scarf in the dark. It wasn't me, Inspector, it wasn't me!'
We asked many more questions, but Fitzroy Simpson did not change his story. He was out at King's Pyland that night, his suit was still wet from the rain, and his big walking stick could break a man's head open. But there were no cuts on his body, so where did the blood on Straker's knife come from?
And where is the horse?
John Stroller's pockets
'Mmm, very interesting,' I said. I gave the papers back to Holmes, and he put them away.
'So, Watson, what can you tell me?' he asked.
I thought for a minute. 'This cut on Straker's leg. Perhaps he did it with his own knife. When something hits you very hard on the head, and you have a knife in your hand… It can happen, you know.'
'Very good, Watson. And that's bad news for Fitzroy Simpson.'
'So did Simpson do it, do you think?' I said.
'Perhaps,' said Holmes. 'Let's look at it. Simpson puts opium in the boy's dinner. He goes away and comes back later in the night. He gets into the stables, takes the horse out, and leaves. But the trainer arrives at that moment, sees him, and follows him. The two men fight, and Simpson breaks Straker's head open with his stick. Then Simpson takes the horse — but where? Or did the horse run away? Is it still out on the moor? And how did Simpson get into the locked stables? I don't know, Watson, I don't know. We must wait and see.'
When we arrived at Tavistock station, two men came to meet us. Inspector Gregory was a tall, slow-moving man with blue eyes, and Mr Ross was small and quick. He was the first to speak.
'Very pleased to see you, Mr Holmes. The Inspector here is working hard, but we need help. We must find poor Straker's killer, and I want to find my horse.'
'Is there any news?' asked Holmes. 'Let's talk on the way,' the Inspector said. 'I'd like you to see everything in the daylight.'
We were soon out of the little town and up on the brown hills of the moor.
Inspector Gregory thought that the killer was Fitzroy Simpson. 'Simpson was out in the rain that night. His suit was still wet on the Tuesday,' he said. 'He had a big stick, and his scarf was in the dead man's hand. That looks bad, Mr Holmes, very bad.'
Holmes smiled. 'You need more than that, Inspector. The servant, Edith, spoke of an envelope. Did Simpson say anything about that?'
'Yes, he said it had money in it — a ten-pound note for the stable boy.'
'What about this other training stables, at Capleton?' asked Holmes. 'Does Simpson have friends there?'
'No, we don't think so. We went to Capleton, of course. Their horse, Desborough, is the second favourite for the Wessex Cup, and Silas Brown, the trainer, was not friendly with Straker. But we found nothing.'
When we arrived at King's Pyland, Inspector Gregory took us into the trainer's house.
'Straker's body is upstairs,' he said. 'But we have here the things from his pockets and from the ground next to his body. Would you like to see them, Mr Holmes?'
'Very much,' said Holmes.
We went into the front room, and the Inspector opened a box and put things on a table. There was a box of matches, a small piece of candle, some money, a watch, some papers, and a small, thin knife.
'This is a strange knife,' Holmes said. He looked at it carefully, and then gave it to me. 'What is it, Watson?'
'It's an eye knife,' I said. 'Doctors use these when they cut into an eye. You don't usually see them outside a hospital.'
'Mm,' said Holmes. 'So why did Straker take this knife? It's no good for fighting.'
'His wife says it was in the bedroom for some days,' said Inspector Gregory. 'Perhaps he just took it because it was there on the table.'
'Perhaps,' said Holmes. 'What about these papers?'
'One is a letter from Mr Ross, the others are bills,' the Inspector said. 'Three of them are bills for the horses' food, and this one is a bill from a dress-maker in London, for a Mr William Darbyshire. He was a friend of Straker's, his wife tells us. His letters sometimes came here, and Straker sent them on.'
'Mrs William Darbyshire is an expensive lady,' said Holmes, looking at the bill. 'Twenty-five pounds is a lot of money, for just one dress and one hat.' He put the bill down and moved to the window. 'Inspector, can we go out on the moor now, before the light begins to go?'
We left the room and at the front door we saw a woman. She came up to Inspector Gregory and put her hand on his arm. 'Is there any news?' she said.
'No, Mrs Straker, but here is Mr Holmes, the famous detective from London. We have him to help us now.'
'I think I met you a month or two ago, Mrs Straker,' said Holmes. 'Let me see… Yes, it was in Plymouth, at a garden-party. Do you remember?'
'No, sir. That wasn't me.'
'But I remember so well… You had a blue dress, and a dark blue hat with white flowers on it.'
'I don't have a hat with flowers on it, sir,' Mrs Straker said.
'Well, well, I am wrong, then. I am so sorry.' And with that Holmes followed the Inspector outside. The four of us then walked past the stables and up onto the moor. After ten minutes Inspector Gregory stopped.
'Here we are,' he said. 'Straker's body was just down there. His coat was here, on this small tree-'
'On the tree? Not on the ground?' Holmes asked. 'Oh no. It was on the tree, carefully away from the mud on the ground.'
'Mmm. Interesting,' said Holmes. 'Now, I must look at the mud down there.'
'Ah,' said Inspector Gregory, 'and to help you, I have here in this bag one of Straker's shoes, one of Fitzroy Simpson's shoes, and one of Silver Blaze's horseshoes.'
'My dear Inspector, well done!' Holmes was very pleased. 'You think of everything.'
For some minutes Holmes looked carefully at the ground, his eyes only centimetres away from the mud.
'Hello!' he said suddenly. 'What's this?' From out of the mud he took a match, or a small piece of one.
'Now why didn't I find that?' said the Inspector.
'I knew it was there, you see,' said Holmes.
'You knew? But how could you know that?'
Holmes smiled but did not answer. He then took the shoes, got down on the ground, and began to look at all the tracks in the mud. We stood and watched him, but after five minutes Mr Ross looked at his watch.
'Er, this is very interesting, Mr Holmes,' he said, 'but is it going to take a long time?'
'No,' said Holmes. He got to his feet. 'I don't need to do any more here. Watson and I are going to take a little walk across the moor now, with the horseshoe.'
Mr Ross looked at the Inspector. 'Can we go back to the house and talk? I must take Silver Blaze's name out of the Wessex Cup race — and do it today, I think.'
'Don't do that!' cried Holmes. 'No, no, you must leave the horse's name in for the race.'
'But...' Mr Ross began. Then he laughed, a little angrily. 'Well, thank you, Mr Holmes. Thank you for your help. See you later then, at the house.'
And he and the Inspector walked away.
Looking for a horse
Holmes and I walked slowly across the moor. In the evening sunlight the autumn colours on the hills were beautiful — reds and browns and yellows.
But Holmes saw nothing of that. 'So, Watson,' he said, 'let's forget John Straker for a minute, and think about the horse. Horses are friendly animals. Let's say that Silver Blaze runs away after the killing. Here he is, out on the cold wet moor. What does he do next?'
'He looks for a nice warm stable,' I said, 'with food and water.'
'Right, Watson. He didn't go back to King's Pyland, we know that, but there is another stable not far away, at Capleton. Perhaps he went there. And the way to Capleton, Watson, is down this hill. Let's go!'
We walked quickly down the hill, and at the bottom we found a small river and some very wet ground.
'Wonderful,' said Holmes. 'I wanted mud, and here it is. You follow the left side of the river, Watson. We're looking for the tracks of horseshoes.'
We found them after only fifty metres. Holmes took the horseshoe out of his pocket and put it next to the tracks. 'Yes, that's Silver Blaze, no question about it.'
We followed the tracks easily, then lost them for a time, but found them again about two hundred metres from the Capleton stables.
'Here they are,' I cried. 'And look — there's another track here, of a man's shoe.'
Holmes got down to look. 'You're right, Watson. And the man is walking next to the horse.'
We followed the two tracks to Capleton stables, and were still twenty metres away when a man came out and called to us. He had a red, angry face.
'Go away! We don't want visitors here! Go away!'
'Mr Silas Brown?' Holmes said to him.
'What do you want?' said the man. 'I don't talk to newspaper people, so just go away.'
'We are not from a newspaper,' said Holmes, smiling. 'But you have a horse called Silver Blaze in your stable.'
'That's not true!' Mr Brown said angrily.
'Shall we go in and talk about it?' said Holmes. He did not wait for an answer, but took the man's arm and moved quickly to the gate. He looked back at me and said quietly, 'Wait for me here, Watson.'
Twenty minutes later they came out again. Holmes looked pleased, and Mr Silas Brown was a different man. He looked smaller and older, and his face was afraid.
'Remember,' said Holmes, 'you must be there on the day, on time, and everything must be ready.'
'Yes, yes,' Silas Brown said quickly. 'You can be sure of it. Oh yes, you can be sure of it.'
'Good,' said Holmes. 'Well, goodbye for now.'
Holmes and I then began to walk back to King's Pyland along the road.
'Does he have the horse, then?' I asked. Holmes laughed. 'Yes. He said no at first, of course, but he's afraid of the police. He doesn't want them to know about this, and I can help him with that.'
'But why didn't the police find the horse?' I asked. 'Inspector Gregory said they went to Capleton.'
'Oh, it's easy to change the colour of a horse's coat.' Holmes laughed again. 'Gregory is a good policeman, but I don't think he knows much about horses.' 'And why did Brown tell you?' I said.
'When I walked through the stables with him,' said Holmes, 'the ground was muddy and I saw the tracks of his shoes in the mud. You remember those tracks on the moor? Well, these were the same shoes. After that, it was easy, and he told me everything. He found Silver Blaze on the moor early in the morning and brought him into the stables. The horse is very well, just a different colour at the moment. Brown put a very big bet on Desborough to win the Wessex Cup, you see. And with Silver Blaze out of the race...'
'But why did you leave the horse there? Is it safe with him?' I did not understand Holmes's plan.
'My dear Watson,' Holmes said, 'the horse is very safe. Silas Brown is afraid of me, afraid of the police, afraid of losing everything. Silver Blaze must be ready to race next week, or Brown's life as a racehorse trainer is finished — and Brown knows that.'
'Mr Ross isn't going to like it,' I said.
'Mr Ross', said Holmes, 'doesn't understand detective work. He wants answers today, now, at once. So, he must learn a lesson. He must learn to wait. Say nothing about Silver Blaze for the moment, Watson.'
Back at King's Pyland, we found Mr Ross and Inspector Gregory in the trainer's house.
'An interesting visit,' said Holmes. 'But my friend and I must go back to London by the midnight train.'
The Inspector and Mr Ross stared at him, and I saw that Holmes was right about Mr Ross.
'So our famous London detective can't find poor Straker's killer,' Mr Ross said. 'Or my horse.'
'It's a difficult case, that's true,' said Holmes quietly. 'But your horse is going to run in the Wessex Cup next Tuesday. You have my promise on that.'
'Hm! A promise is a wonderful thing,' said Mr Ross. 'But I would like the horse better than a promise.'
Holmes smiled, then turned to Inspector Gregory. 'Inspector, can you give me a photograph of Straker?'
'Yes, of course,' said the Inspector. He took one from an envelope in his pocket and gave it to Holmes.
It was now time to go back to Tavistock, and we went outside. One of the stable boys was there, and Holmes suddenly spoke to him.
'I see you have some sheep here, next to the stables,' he said. 'Are they all well?'
'They're all right, sir,' said the boy, 'but two or three of them are a little lame. They went lame last week.'
Holmes was very pleased about this. He got into the carriage and said to the Inspector, 'Remember the lame sheep, Gregory, remember the lame sheep!'
Mr Ross was not interested in the sheep, but the Inspector stared at Holmes. 'You think the sheep are important?'
'Oh yes,' said Holmes. 'Very important.' The Inspector still stared at him, very interested now.
'And what other things are important, Mr Holmes?'
'The strange incident of the dog in the night-time.'
'The dog did nothing in the night-time.'
'That was the strange incident.'
A day at the races
On Tuesday Holmes and I took the train to Winchester, and Mr Ross met us at the station. He drove us to the races, but he was not a happy man.
'Well, Mr Holmes,' he said coldly. 'Do you have news of my horse?'
Holmes smiled. 'He's safe and well, I'm sure. How is the betting for the Wessex Cup?'
'Very strange,' said Mr Ross. 'Yesterday Silver Blaze was fifteen to one, but today he's the favourite, at three to one. Why, I don't know.'
'Ah!' said Holmes. 'Somebody knows something!'
We arrived only minutes before the beginning of the Wessex Cup race. This was Holmes's plan, I think. Mr Ross had no time to ask questions. There were six horses running in the race, and Silver Blaze's name was there, at number 4. The horses began to come out for the race, and Mr Ross got very excited.
'Where is he? I can't see him!' he cried.
'There are two more horses to come out,' I said. 'And look! There's number 4 now, in racing colours of red and blue. Those are your colours, Mr Ross.'
And there was Silver Blaze, a big brown horse with a white nose. He came past us, looking strong and well, and ready for anything.
'Holmes,' cried Mr Ross, 'I was wrong about you! I'm sorry. But why, how-?'
'Shh!' said Holmes. 'Watch! Yes, they're off!'
It was a good race, fast and exciting. After the first minute, a horse with yellow racing colours came to the front, and stayed there.
'That's Desborough, from the Capleton stables,' said Holmes. 'A good horse, but Silver Blaze is better.'
But Silver Blaze was three horses behind Desborough.
'Come on, come on!' cried Mr Ross. 'Move up now!'
We all watched the red and blue colours. 'Yes!' I said. 'Look, he's moving up now! Watch him go!'
Slowly but surely, Silver Blaze moved up into fourth place, then into third place, then into second place. Now only Desborough was in front of him.
Eighty metres, fifty metres… 'He's away!' cried Mr Ross. 'His nose is in front, yes, yes, he's going to do it!'
And he did. Silver Blaze kept his nose in front, finished first, and won the Wessex Cup.
'Wonderful!' said Mr Ross. 'Wonderful! What a race! What a horse! Mr Holmes, how can I thank you?'
'You must thank the horse, not me,' said Holmes, smiling. 'Let's go down and have a look at him.'
Silver Blaze was still excited by his big race. Mr Ross looked him up and down. 'He looks well, very well. I don't understand any of it, Mr Holmes. How did you do it? Where did you find him? And perhaps you now have John Straker's killer too. Do you?'
'Yes,' said Holmes quietly. 'Yes, I have him too.'
Mr Ross and I stared at him. 'You have him?' Mr Ross said. 'Where is he?'
'He is here.'
'Here with me now, at this moment.'
Mr Ross's face began to go red. 'What are you saying, Mr Holmes?' he said angrily. 'Are you saying-?'
Sherlock Holmes laughed. 'No, no, Mr Ross, not you. The killer is standing behind us.'
He turned and put his hand on Silver Blaze's back.
'The horse?' cried Mr Ross.
'The horse!' I said.
'Yes, the horse,' said Holmes. 'But don't be angry with him. You can hear all about the mystery, but later, please. I have a little bet on a horse in the next race, and I would like to see it win...'
Holmes has the answers
On the train back to London Holmes told us the story behind the mystery, and the time went very quickly.
'Before we went down to King's Pyland,' my friend began, 'I thought it was Fitzroy Simpson. But when we arrived at the stables, I suddenly remembered the hot meat curry. Why didn't I think of it before? That, you see, was the beginning.'
'The meat curry...' said Mr Ross, thinking about it. 'Er, how did the meat curry help you?'
'Do you know the taste of opium?' Holmes said. 'No? Well, it's not a very strong taste, but it's there. You can taste it in most food, but not in curry. Curry has a very strong taste, stronger than opium. So the killer says, «I need a night when the dinner is a meat curry. Then Ned Hunter can eat his dinner happily, without the taste of opium — and go to sleep.» But did Fitzroy Simpson know that curry was the dinner on Monday night? Of course not. How could he? He didn't make the dinner, he was a stranger at King's Pyland, he knew nobody in the trainer's house. So, we forget Simpson, and think again. Who knew about the curry before dinner on that Monday night?'
'John Straker and his wife,' I said. 'And the servant.'
'Right, Watson. And so on to the next question, about the dog. We know there was a dog in the stables that night because Ned Hunter took the dog out when Simpson was there. Then in the middle of the night someone went into the stables and took out a horse. The two boys sleeping upstairs in the stables heard nothing, because there was nothing to hear. The dog did not bark. Why not?'
'Aha!' said Mr Ross. 'It didn't bark, because it knew the visitor. Dogs only bark at strangers.'
'Right again. So, the midnight visitor was John Straker. But why did he take the horse out? What did he want? It was something dishonest, or why did he put opium in his stable boy's dinner? We all know about dishonest trainers. They can make a lot of money — they put big bets against their own horse, and then stop their horse winning. But how? What was Straker's plan here? Perhaps the answer was in his pockets, I thought.
'And so it was. You remember the strange knife? Dr Watson here told us about it — an eye knife, used by doctors in hospitals. With a knife like this, you can make a cut — a very, very small cut — in the tendon of a horse's back leg. Nobody can see the cut, and the horse only feels it a little. He's not lame, but he doesn't run his best, so he cannot win the race.'
'And Straker wanted to do this to my horse?' cried Mr Ross. 'How could he? I thought he was a good man!'
'No,' said Holmes. 'He wasn't a good man — or a careful one. No horse stands quietly when a knife goes into its back leg. Straker didn't want anyone to hear the noise, so he took the horse out onto the moor.'
'The candle, and the match,' I said. 'Of course!'
'That's right,' Holmes said. 'And I learnt more from Straker's pockets too. You are a man of the world, Mr Ross. Do men carry other men's bills around in their pockets? No, they do not. So who was Mr Darbyshire? Another name for John Straker. And there was a lady in the case, too. A very expensive lady. I talked to Mrs Straker about the dress and the hat on the bill, but she knew nothing about them.'
'And on Monday night, out on the moor,' said Mr Ross, 'what happened, do you think?'
'How about this?' said Holmes. 'Straker takes the horse down the hill. He sees Simpson's scarf on the ground, and takes it with him — why, I don't know. He puts his coat on a tree, gets out the candle and the matches, and the knife, and begins his work. But Silver Blaze doesn't like it. Perhaps he's afraid, perhaps he feels something is wrong. He's a big strong horse, and he gets angry. He kicks out with his back legs, and the horseshoes hit Straker on the head. Straker goes down, into the mud, and the knife in his hand goes into his own leg. The horse disappears into the night.'
'Wonderful!' Mr Ross said. 'You tell it very well, Mr Holmes. I see it all now.'
'And the sheep?' I asked. 'What about the sheep? You told Inspector Gregory that they were important.'
'Ah yes, Watson, the sheep.' Holmes smiled. 'And they were important. It's not easy to make a very small cut in an animal's tendon, and Straker did not want to get it wrong. He needed to practise first, but what on? There were his own sheep, right in front of him.'
'And where did you go in London, the day after we got back?' I asked. 'Was it to that dress-maker on the bill for Mr Darbyshire?'
'Very good, Watson!' Holmes laughed. 'Yes, I had a photograph of Straker, and the dress-maker knew him at once. «Oh yes,» she said, «that's Mr Darbyshire. I do a lot of work for him. Mrs Darbyshire is a very beautiful lady, and she likes expensive dresses.»' Holmes laughed again. 'It's an old, old story. Straker is not the first man with two women in his life. He needed more money for the expensive Mrs Darbyshire, so he thought of this plan with Silver Blaze. And there you have it, Mr Ross.'
'Yes, I understand it all now,' said Mr Ross, 'and thank you very much, Mr Holmes. There's just one thing. Where was the horse?'
'Ah, yes. The horse was safe and well, and with a friend,' said Sherlock Holmes, I can't tell you who or where, because I made a promise. But here we are, nearly in London. You have the answer to the mystery, Mr Ross, you are the winner of the Wessex Cup, and the owner of the fastest racehorse in the south of England. What more do you need?'